This page contains the following solutions.
Mix sugar-free Cool Whip with a mandarin orange. It tastes just like a creamsicle.
Mix equal parts of store bought chocolate icing and marshmallow cream. Microwave for 15 seconds. Keep an eye on it or it can boil over. You could use any flavor icing you like.
Instead of using milk or cream, use bananas and cashews instead for a diet friendly version. This is a page about making healthy choconana cashew ice cream.
Crush the peanut butter cookies in a plastic bag, Blend sugar, margarine and cream cheese. Then blend in Cool Whip. Mix the 2 packages of pudding with the milk until slightly hard.