My husband was raised in the area of Cairo, Illinois. There was a bakery there that I believed was named Eddie's Pastries. They had a dessert called "butter top coffee cake" that people still rave about even 40 years later. On the web I have seen what people believe to be THE recipe, but each time my husband declares it is not the same. I have spent years kissing too many frogs trying to make this childhood memory come to pass.
We have experienced the vast unemployment like so many of you and have been unemployed for one year. My husband's birthday is quickly approaching and this may be his only gift. If anyone has what they believe to be THE recipe, please share it. Just any coffee cake or gooey butter cake recipe will not do. I am told they are simply not the same. I would so appreciate any and all help in this matter. If you are the holder of a true original recipe I will be forever grateful, as will my husband. Thanks everyone!
By Marla from USA
You might already have this recipe. I've never tried it, so I can't offer any advice on any adjustments, etc. Good luck on your search! I know it can be very frustrating when you're looking for that special recipe from long ago. Have a great evening!
Cake
Directions:
Eat and die a happy person!
Topping
Directions:
By JB
I suspect what you are looking for is the St. Louis "Gooey Butter Cake". In Cairo they probably called it butter top. It is the best cake in the world and I wish I had some now. If they have a Dearburgs (I may have spelled that wrong) in Cairo they might carry it there. Other Dearburgs in Illinois have it. If you can't find a recipe buy the gooey butter. I think he will recognize it. (07/08/2010)
By Lilac
Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!
Ed & Tobe Grueninger were my great uncle and aunt. I grew up eating that butter cake. I now live in the St. Louis area. I can assure you that Uncle Ed's butter cake tasted NOTHING like the gooey butter cake in St. Louis. The closest I have found that is pre-made is Kruta's in Collinsville, IL...and it is a distant second to his. He just made a little slice of heaven.
My sister married Ed's son. They ran the bakery after Ed retired. I know for a fact that none of these recipes are correct, I was given a copy of the original, but was told not to share. It was a family recipe, and they called it Butter Top coffee cake, which was a best seller.
Oh my goodness!! That is so sad to hear! Ive tried every recipe that I have come across and you are correct they do not compare! Back then the butter top was a staple and readily available to us in Cairo that we took it for granted and now it is part of our past we long for! Since the family cant share the recipe the family should host a Butter Top Coffee Cake event in Cairo in honor of Eddies Bakery!
Add your voice! Click below to comment. ThriftyFun is powered by your wisdom!