Finding an Old Children's Story Cassette Tape?

So when I was a kid I had this children's Christian story/musical audio cassette tape that I would listen to every night. I really wanna find it again or at least know it's name. The story was about this kid who didn't want to play with this other kid because he thought he looked weird. So the kid gets grounded for being rude and while he's asleep he gets washed away onto this island. On this island there are a bunch of beings who kinda look like Bone from the graphic novel series Bone, but fuzzy and each one's fur was a single color. They tell the boy to avoid the one with the plaid fur because he was abnormal and strange and a bad person. The boy avoids him and even runs away from him until he finds himself talking to him. He finds out he's nothing like the other beings said, he's just avoided because he's different. He finds out that none of the others had even gotten close enough to even get to know him. The boys learns that it's wrong to judge people on looks alone and when he goes home/wakes up he apologises and decides to actually get to know the other kid. I remember one song from it called, "Time In My Room" and I can even sing a single line. It went like this: "Spending time in my room, filled with stress filled with gloom, did a bad thing and then boom, I'm doing time here in my room." Yeah weird right. Anyway does anyone remember this or know where I can find out? I drew a pic of what I kinda remember the beings looking like. I don't think it's accurate, but maybe it'll help jog someone's memory. I've been looking for ages, but it's like it never existed.